Normal Game Thread Elsword Mafia Game Thread

What do you mean in the bold?

 

Just curious, but is Ratchet an actual Scum read, or are you just going to continue to vote people you want to talk to?

Was going to attempt rereading the thread, but I decided going for a walk with my brother and then meeting up with my buddy and his fiance would be a better use of time. That said:

I'm not really sure what you expect me to say? I think the gamestate for this game is kinda chaotic. There are the active posters and then the posters who don't post. This makes the game pretty chaotic because people are likely to take hard stances on the active players in the game, in my experience at least. IDK why you are giving Prada "the benefit of the doubt" so to speak in the way you are giving them a Town read for IDK what reason (if you stated this, please point it out). Would like to see more from Stink because he seems to kinda have his head on strait. Doesn't mean he is Town (because his activity is mostly NAI), just means that he seems like a logical kind of guy and I'd like to see more from him. I see you are trying to take the lead this game. I don't think this is a bad or good thing, it just is. I know that I myself do not have the ability to have perfect Town reads at this stage of the game, so IDK why you are so firm thinking Scum HAS to be in this group of 8. I say this knowing my Town reads are generally pretty good, so no, I wouldn't agree that your other Town reads are "lock clear" by any stretch of the imagination. Also, I'm not sure you understand my case on Ans? You didn't comment on it so IDK what you are thinking about it.

I'm going to give a reads list, but I don't put much faith in it at this point simply because I am used to games with a lot more activity and so its hard to get good reads when a lot of players are not even posting and the others don't have a ton of content to go through. It also has to do with the kind of content this game has had. Its not what I am used to. I am used to players being a bit more analytical and having a bit more to say about things. That's not a diss to anyone in this game, its just that I am having a little difficulty reading players this game.

Town:

GloBear
SK

Lean Town:

Prada

Null:

Panda
Rice
Rise
Stink
Emily

Lean Scum:

Shock
Ans

 

If making a case against Soulkiller is appealing to me, then cindarella would have also done it.

 

Well since i keep saying i suspect him and all of that - yes i thought it was pretty clear it was also a scum read

Aaah i see?

 

As an aside, I am kinda curious how much investigative power Town has this game. The mod told me claiming was not allowed in this game, so its more just me pondering about balance more than anything.

Sorry, had to get that off my chest.

 

Since we all three made a case against Soulkiller on the same basis to begin with. I also don't see how Ratchet appealed to me when Soulkiller and I had my argument. From my pov he was also reacting in a scummy way. Case in point I don't think Ratchet went out of his way on SK to buddy with me.

 

Forgot Ratchet (didn't count right). Ratchet is Null.

 

Musings i see but you did not bring it up at the time? Why not?

 

I am town myself and you guys tried to make connections of me and Ratchet as scumteam. I also don't feel like he was buddying with me. Overall a rather weak argument in my eyes.

 

She ded, as in modkilled, if no one subs by the end of this day phase

ewe

 

What is your read on Ratchet currently?

 

Yes but if you thought he was acting oddly, why did you not bring it up?

 

What is your take on how to read Ratchet?

 

Based on what Prada said. Sorry should have included that.

 

Going to bed, will try and be on by EOD.