1. Hey, Guest! Do you want to chat with us? Then come to the chat thread Here!
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Welcome to Sugoi Desu, Respected Guest! Please take a moment to register today.

Which is better?

Discussion in 'General Industry Discussion' started by Kame, May 31, 2015.

  1. Kame Heaven's Feel

    Messages
    9,481
    11,175
    Trophy Points
    12,088
    Keno
    4,656,411ლ
    Tokyo Ghoul

    Or

    Parasyte
    One is quite older than the other, but it recently go an anime, and it was quite a great anime at that. Comparing manga to manga, i'd give the edge to tokyo ghoul, while comparing both anime, parasyte takes it by a long shot. These are both great in their own way, and thought it'd be a great comparison. Some info about each series can be found below.

    Tokyo ghoul; The suspense horror/dark fantasy story is set in Tokyo, which is haunted by mysterious "ghouls" who are devouring humans. People are gripped by the fear of these ghouls whose identities are masked in mystery. An ordinary college student named Kaneki encounters Rize, a girl who is an avid reader like him, at the café he frequents. Little does he realize that his fate will change overnight.

    Parasyte; The 17-year-old Izumi Shinichi lives with his mother and father in a quiet neighborhood in Tokyo. One night, worm-like aliens called Parasytes invade Earth, taking over the brains of human hosts by entering through their ears or noses. One Parasyte attempts to crawl into Shinichi's ear while he sleeps, but fails since he is wearing headphones, and enters his body by burrowing into his arm instead, taking over his right hand and is named Migi.

    Because Shinichi was able to prevent Migi from traveling further up into his brain, both beings retain their separate intellect and personality. As the duo encounter other Parasytes, they capitalize on their strange situation and gradually form a strong bond, working together to survive. This gives them an edge in battling other Parasytes, who frequently attack the pair upon realization that Shinichi's human brain is still intact. Shinichi feels compelled to fight other Parasytes, who devour humans as food, while enlisting Migi's help.

    With that said, what are your thoughts?
     
  2. AirConditioner Der Rosenkavalier Schwarzwald

    Messages
    428
    99
    Trophy Points
    260
    Keno
    102ლ
    Tokyo Ghoul. More entertaining story, better main character, more likeable cast in general, better symbolism, writting, etc.

    Parasyte is bland. Just tries to represent itself in an intellectual way. Whole point of the protagonist is that humans can't kill due to emotions. Basically, just having a monster in his body and being forced to fight. <- I just described to you his whole mental state. Bland. They just try to cover it up with some attempts at ''smart'' quotes.

    He gets development, except his development is kinda shit and he just swaps his way of functioning with the monster at one point. He is now more robotic while the monster is more human.

    They just swap roles. That's not really well thought out. The plot itself is really repititive with the whole ''Parasytes starting to become more human, etc.'' shit. It also has some kind of an obvious enviromental message? No one is really likeable in the show... Maybe Kana who died literally a few episodes after she was introduced.

    TL;DR; I dislike Parasyte and do not understand why people think it's good. Tokyo Ghoul has a more likeable and better written protagonist as well as the massive amounts of symbolism and less repititve story that are better than Parasyte.

    Though, anime-wise... Parasyte is better. TG has a particulary bad adaption.
     
    Kame and Kaito like this.
  3. Kame Heaven's Feel

    Messages
    9,481
    11,175
    Trophy Points
    12,088
    Keno
    4,656,411ლ
    Well, for the most part the characters are supposed to be like that, but i don't think kana is the only good character. I'll tell you a few for example.

    Migi; He started out as a cold hearted being, and even threatened to kill people around shinichi, and even mentioned that he'd only protect him to protect himself. Though, as the story progressed, migi started to care more for shinichi, even going out of his way to save him, also saved his girl at the end. Plus, overall, i feel migi was a good character.

    Satomi; She was alright, nothing great, her and shinichi had a lot of bad moments, but in the end she accepted him as he was.

    Reiko; Might possibly be the best character in the series, she went from being an un caring person, to even having a kid, and protecting it until the very end, that last moment with her was sad. ;_;


    Alright, as for plot wise, it's not just about that. Apparently someone thought it was a great idea to make parasytes in order to level out life on earth? That was the point for them being there, as a counter for humans. But yeah, the parasyte being more human bs got repetitive towards the end.
    ............................................

    With that said, it might be different for others, but by no means is it bad. It could have been better, but oh well. The anime was done greatly, imo.

    I prefer tokyo ghoul, always will. That's my fav mango. : D
     
    AC likes this.
  4. AirConditioner Der Rosenkavalier Schwarzwald

    Messages
    428
    99
    Trophy Points
    260
    Keno
    102ლ
    I wasn't really talking about her being a good character though. Likeability refers to how enjoyable the character is when on screen, personality-wise. Kana had a nice personality and she was enjoyable when on screen, I suppose. Don't think she's well characterized. Shinichi, I didn't like because his personality came down to his fear towards the situation he was placed in which didn't quite appeal to me. Migi was somewhat alright, I suppose.

    That's kind of what I meant with the whole swapping of roles thing. They both basically just developed into the exact opposite of what they were in the beginning. Not particulary an interesting idea. And it's been done with a lot of other characters in this series which is kind of repititive as well. Their world-view, personality quirks, the way they go about acting upon things, etc. are all either non-existant or just very short by being related to the whole ''Humans can't think like machines because they have emotions'' message the show is trying to convey.

    Swapping roles is an old trick, really. Not hard to pull off. Which is why I kinda consider the whole thing mediocre. Though, what matters is execution and the execution wasn't good for me. Because like I said, their whole world-views, problems, personality, way of acting upon things, philosophy, ideology, etc. was either

    a) Just a reflection of their disgust for opposite role (in the beginning of the series) or a disgust for themselves for developing into said role (at the end of the series).
    b) Just wasn't there or was really unexpanded upon.

    I mean the whole thing with Shinichi's mother was kind of eh for me. I expected it to happen the moment she left the house for a trip. Predictability isn't a specifically bad thing. It's just that it was used as a device to change Shinichi's and Migi's roles and didn't really do much effect otherwise. Kind of wasn't a fan of that.

    I didn't like her. She was just an emotional support for Shinichi. Not a character herself.

    Oh, I'm not particulary saying it's bad. I've gave it a 6/10 in my MAL while most people gave it a 7-10/10. I mean, I kind of got into the series because people told me it's great and the best anime of it's season, but it kind of turned bland for me. Which is why I don't really like it.
     
  5. Mahesvara Lostbelt King

    mahes
    Messages
    6,373
    1,899
    Trophy Points
    2,240
    Keno
    1,357ლ
    Going by the animes for both, Parasyte was better IMO
     
  6. Zexion~ Regular Member

    Messages
    105
    7
    Trophy Points
    0
    Keno
    4ლ
    Both are terrible and monster solo's
     

Share This Page