Normal Game Thread [Mafia Lovers] Death Note #6

Hmm, so we can't pseudo-vote. Well, at least we got a change to change our votes.
I agree that most seem to have been active. I didn't really check as such but I feel I saw enough users posting. So inactives won't be much of a concern

Since we can discuss the tips, it might be best for us to share them. Though before doing so, I'd prefer to know other's opinion whether it's a good idea or not, considering that the Mafia will also know what the tips are and might adjust accordingly to not be suspected..

 

discussing the tips would be a starting point, but if mafia are 2 people and the gm gives us even 1 fake clue, it'd make 3/6 clues inaccurate or even misleading. Trusting a clue here is an act of faith.

that said, maybe we can work on each clue's truth value, judging from the kind of clue it is. For example, i think the one i got is vague enough to be actually true.

 

True, 50% true 50% false doesn't sound like of much use.

Hmm, maybe we could, but I doubt it'll be easy to judge them. From what I gather from the hint system, it's a hint about the player. It'll not be hard to give out a hint of another play for the host, even if he's not Mafia, so I'm not really sure if that'll work

 

Claim what exactly?

I don't really think the hints would bluntly be false. Because the first post says it'll be some info(even though vague) about the mafia lovers so I highly doubt it'll be untrue.

And, I am in favour of sharing the tips tbh.

 

Have you requested a tip yet?

 

well, yeah. i just discovered my clue isn't vague at all lol

so basically, it told me the mafia are a newbie member and an old member, pretty much. After a quick glance, of 4/6 players are newer than me, and only 1 is older. Unless the clue is fake, it points into a pretty clear direction.

@Venomous Cobra, i'm about to vote you because you're an oldie. show up and defend yourself from this age discrimination.

 

Can you tell me who are the newbie players? I know Silver and myself are new but what about the others?

 

lio (posted in page1) and bimbonium (posted in page2)

but... as a matter of fact, i've just noticed bimbonium IS older than me, even if he has the "newbie member" user title because he didn't post a whole lot. So, hmm.

waiting for an input from cobra for now, since he's still the stronger lead according to the clue and to his inactivity.

 

Actually, I too find Cobra's post weird(the one that I quoted). He supports the "lynching an inactive" theory, says it doesn't really work coz no one fits that category even though there were people who barely posted(Lio for example). Then he suggests claiming (claiming what?) And then random lynching. Why? How will that help?

 

Not yet, I want to observe without having my judgement affected from a hint for now.

 

Roles but again it's just risky for this number of players.

 

Lmao I dindu nuffin

Anyway, I don't have much to say really. I'm not that experienced, I'm pretty trash actually. I lose more often than I win, plus I'm only good at starting bandwagons lol.

Claiming helps us not only with starting somewhere instead of wasting time looking at shallow leads such as activity in a small game that had already gone for 24+ hours now, but also finding out who is lying and who is not. Even if we reveal our main Investigation role(L or shinigamai), plus this kira can't kill directly in this version if I understand correctly, thus claiming is even better . The very nature of claiming is risky but it is most definitely not as risky as lynching a heavy town role based on a rushed hunch little before the lynch phase deadline (which is how this convo is seemingly going)


Surely, when I suggest "let's ask someone to claim", Im including myself and I'm ready to do so, nothing important to reveal anyway.

 

How is claiming roles gonna help? Isn't it clear what roles are present in the game?

Lynching a heavy town role, huh.. Have you read the rules, sir?

 

When do you plan to request it?

 

Yub

NVm, I was thinking of the old version just read the rules, act like this didn't happen lol.