Normal Game Thread Full Metal Panic!: Fighting Boy Meets Girl Mafia

SK · Jul 22, 2017

Good game everyone, was fun while it lasted ^^

Thanks Ratchet for hosting the game.

Shanksette · Jul 23, 2017

Yeah thanks for the game @Ratchet and sorry for joining a game while I knew that busy week was coming u_u' I won't do it again

Railgun99 · Jul 23, 2017

Rotaretilbo said: ↑

Eh, I'd say gg, but I don't feel like we played on. I'll just go down the list.

@Globear Now that the game is done, we can shed all this "I suspect Rot for disagreeing with me" nonsense. You claiming was bad. That's not an opinion, it's an objective fact. It didn't accomplish any of the things you claimed it would, and ultimately actively harmed the Town. I don't think it wound up mattering much in the end, but please try and think things through next time. Claiming unbidden when you're an important role and have nothing to offer immediately is basically never good for Town.

@Ningen git fukt

@Lord Maple Your few posts are meaningful, but I think too far between. Not much else to say.

@Crimson Falcon Your reaction to Prada's hate boner for you honestly made Prada seem more reasonable. Throughout the game, you treated yourself like the rest of us should consider you confirmed Town. Especially on Day 4, with your wishywashy arguments where you'd make an assertion but only accept some of the repercussions of that assertion, you were incredibly suspicious and not very helpful. Likewise, you stated that Katyusha was certainly Scum, but pushed for a lynch on me, whom you believed to be probably Scum, which I think was pretty silly. Also pretty silly to place such an early vote in LyLo.

@Crispickle I just don't feel like you thought anything through. Asking Glob if she was going to self-protect was silly and pointless, your treating Falcon as confirmed Town for no reason at all made no sense, but more than anything, I can't believe that we were in LyLo, a situation where Scum typically need one wrongly placed vote to speedlynch, and you placed a "placeholder" vote. Please be more careful with your vote.

@Prada Lynching the Miller is not the correct Day 1 play. You spent so much time focused on Falcon that you drove your partner to suspect you.

@Rotaretilbo I mean, you little shit, playing vidja instead of posting during the last 24 hours of Day 1. What kind of piece of shit does that? And I can't believe you pussed out and didn't call out SK's botched roleclaim. Give Ratchet more credit, next time.

@Railgun99 You didn't leave much of an impression, beyond your claim. I'll note that you oughtn't claim unbidden like that. Beyond that, just try to be more active. I know that you're new to this type of mafia, but don't let feeling overwhelmed stop you from posting.

@poutanko I expected better from you. Your suspicion of Prada was incredibly poorly conceived, and lynching daoko based on what was easily a coincidental relation to somehow prove it was even less thought through. And I feel like you repeatedly ignored my points in the process of pushing my lynch. I honestly thought you must be Scum when you hammered me.

@Shanksette I'm kinda disappointed with how little time you gave this game. I feel like you're capable of better.

@Dr. White I don't actually have any complaints for you. No compliments either, but you're probably the only player (including myself) for whom I have no critiques, and that's not nothing.

@Katyusha Didn't really get a good feeling for you from our brief interactions.

@daoko Only got a day with you, but I'll say that your conflating "Innocent" "Green" and "Vanilla" was pretty dumb. I addressed it somewhere, but I'm too lazy to find it.

@EvilGenius In retrospect, I get not wanting to name claim, and I definitely get lying about your role. However, I do feel like you were really wishy washy all game, like you weren't paying much attention. And, as I expressed when it happened, I thought it was dumb that you threw a vote out super early in what we believed was LyLo.

@SK I don't feel like you played particularly well, but you didn't play super bad either. You botched the claim, but I'm to understand it was sort of a miscommunication with Ratchet. The role you were looking for was Observant, not Observer, and you needed to have a Faith in there to signify the 50% fail chance. Ratchet also doesn't use the / for hybrid stuff, but some hosts (like myself) do, so that's not as big a deal.

@Ratchet Ultimately, I think you overcompensated for the faction count just a little bit. Because the SK was alone, a lot of normal scumtells were nulled, and having such a strong safe claim couple with having two full kills and also there being a Princess and two Lovers and if the Princess died after both Lovers then the SK earned an extra kill, I think you could have toned it back just a little bit. Probably would have given the SK like Ghost for N0 only, though. Otherwise, game was fine.
Click to expand...

thank you rot. Appreciate it ^^ I know, I was feeling a bit overwhelmed actually so you're right ^^

Ratchet · Aug 30, 2017

Game MVP:

SK - Medium Gameplay
Dr White - Medium Gameplay

daoko - Low Gameplay
Railgun99 - Low Gameplay
Lord Maple- Low Gameplay
Panda 1 Konobi - Low Gameplay
Crimson Falcon - Low Gameplay
poutanko - Low Gameplay
Crispickle - Low Gameplay
Globear - Low Gameplay
EvilGenius - Low Gameplay
Rotaretilbo - Low Gameplay
Shanksette - Low Gameplay
Katyusha - Low Gameplay
Ningen - Low Gameplay

This initially looks rather harsh, but I'm not using "Low gameplay" as "low quality overall". I felt like White and SK was a step above, but a lot of players I felt struggled with their activity or to make much of an impact. I also felt like SK had his job made a fair bit easier for him by Town, though he would still be my pick for MVP. The few night actions people made didn't really change the game so I haven't factored that in much.

cc @Rohan

Mentions (open) Mentions (close)

@SK
@Ningen
@Astralaria
@Railgun99
@Lord Maple
@Globear
@Punk
@Shanksette
@Dr. White
@Rotaretilbo
@EvilGenius
@Crimson Falcon
@poutanko
@Crispickle
@Katyusha

Apologies for the delay on this.

Rohan · Aug 30, 2017

@Ratchet
@SK
@Ningen
@Astralaria
@Railgun99
@Lord Maple
@Globear
@Punk
@Shanksette
@Dr. White
@Rotaretilbo
@EvilGenius
@Crimson Falcon
@poutanko
@Crispickle
@Katyusha

Vote for MVP please.

MVP Candidates are:-

@SK

@Dr. White

Katyusha · Aug 30, 2017

MVP Vote: SK

Glowbeary · Aug 30, 2017

Mvp vote : Sk

Easy choice +.+

Crispickle · Aug 31, 2017

mvp vote: dr.white

sk is gonna win it and he deserves it fully, but i think dr.white played the cleanest game and made the perfect use of his cop role. I agree with ratchet that he's by far the best townie for the little i remember.

Aeryn · Aug 31, 2017

dr.white

Rotaretilbo · Sep 2, 2017

Dr. White

Crimson Falcon · Sep 2, 2017

sk

Ratchet · Sep 2, 2017

SK - 4 (Ratchet, Katyusha, Globear, Crimson falcon)
Dr. White - 3 (Crispickle, Astralaria (daoko), Rotaretilbo)

Rohan · Sep 18, 2017

The MVP Vote Tally:-

@SK - 4 (Ratchet, Katyusha, Globear, Crimson falcon)
@Dr. White - 3 (Crispickle, Astralaria (daoko), Rotaretilbo)

@SK is the MVP of the game! Congratulations!

With that all prizes of the game will be distributed soon.

Log in or Sign up

Normal Game Thread Full Metal Panic!: Fighting Boy Meets Girl Mafia

SK SoulKiller

Shanksette Snekh

Railgun99 Scarecrow ◤(¬‿¬)◥

Ratchet Advanced Member

Rohan Guest

Katyusha ☭URA!☭

Glowbeary Tentacle Taco +.+

Crispickle christmassy feeling

Aeryn daydream in blue

Rotaretilbo Regular Member

Crimson Falcon pussy lounge

Ratchet Advanced Member

Rohan Guest

Share This Page

Log in or Sign up

Normal Game Thread Full Metal Panic!: Fighting Boy Meets Girl Mafia

SK SoulKiller

Shanksette Snekh

Railgun99 Scarecrow ◤(¬‿¬)◥

Ratchet Advanced Member

Rohan Guest

Katyusha ☭URA!☭

Glowbeary Tentacle Taco +.+

Crispickle christmassy feeling

Aeryn daydream in blue

Rotaretilbo Regular Member

Crimson Falcon pussy lounge

Ratchet Advanced Member

Rohan Guest

Share This Page

Useful Searches