Normal Game Thread Big Trouble in Little Salem

Lol, what are the reasons behind them?

 

That was inappropriately worded, I was referring to this particular mislynch.

 

I think I made that rather clear, no?

 

But it's good to know what one thinks what everyone shares is useful it allows us to strengthen an argument ot draw similarities

Quick and Crismon Reaper as mentioned previously +.+

 

No, the argument was more personal than anything else, you guys even started talking about mislynches in past games no one here knows about, proceeding with the lynch for a reason as such is scummy as hell.

 

I agree thinks like sleeping, mislynches in past games should just be left really it just distracts all the players from the task at hand

 

I'm of the opinion people will fine-tune their behaviours to an extent if hunches are all you can bring against them.

I'll share one for the sake of discussion tho,
Lord Maple - his post at the beginning of dp 2 came across as a "what? Why didn't my kill go through"

 

Musings i personally didnt see anything odd there, although ill read over it

 

Ironically, if past game between Ningen and Ratchet are anything to go by, then Ratchet is scum in this one, since he never mislynches when Viole is a host or a participant. This isn't my argument tho, it's just fun to point out.

 

@Globear these two posts

Then there's his last phase lurking and general inactivity.

 

Appeal to tradition

 

Well if that's what you got from it that you totally missed the point. Viole made a statement intended to discredit my character (and thus, work against my push for his lynch) by claiming that I "usually push mislynches". I explained how, from his perspective, that could not be true. That wasn't ego stroking, that was showing how his statement was clearly false, and that he also knew it as false, but tried to discredit my position through it anyway. The actual mislynch thing had nothing to do with the lynch itself - it was the fact that Viole was making deliberately false remarks to argue against his lynch which was scummy.

It's the same reason that Viole calling Crimson "a shit" wasn't in and of itself scummy. It was rude, for sure, but not scummy. What was scummy was how he tried to claim he hadn't said so, and then, instead of demonstrating what he meant, first tried to claim I was putting words into his mouth, and then tried to claim that, because he said he wasn't aimed at who it seemed to be aimed at, that was enough, and he didn't need to demonstrate how he expected anyone to follow that. He then went forward again with the "you're putting words in my mouth" claim, didn't even bother to defend his claims and when he then came up with the above (see: first paragraph) that was enough to settle it for me.

So no, the argument wasn't more personal than anything else, and honestly I'm not sure I like how woefully off the mark you are in presenting the argument, because I don't see how anyone who actually read it could come to the conclusion you seem to have come to.

 

I didn't say never. Just not often. I mislynched twice in one game where he was a host.

 

Did you even read the post you quoted?

 

I actually wouldn't mind something from bim as well. Seems a bit blendy with posts like he is kinda just looking st the obvious choices and retaining info discussed.

I keep feeling like CR is just newer, but I can't let them go for some reason. Can still see scum.