Normal Game Thread Big Trouble in Little Salem

Not really sure who to vote for, to be honest. The day has kind of just come and gone and I don't feel like I've gotten anywhere.

 

@Globear based on what little information i have, you should probably also include that i aint scum, don't you think my teammates would be helping me out, I'm in the dark just as you.

 

conclude*

 

Tch! You forgot the part where I didn't want to share who I think is scummy without having something "substantial" against them, then I obliged you for the sake of discussion and this is what you've got? Nice.

 

Prada's posts (open) Prada's posts (close)

Defend too much? Jesus ******* christ. People were ganging up on him and I stepped in. You know maybe let the guy catch a little a break? Divert attention? I called out something I felt was scummy. Which I also felt was overlooked by everyone. How about you guys just start reading better, so I don't have point out bullshit here.

Yeah that amazing fluff post. You know I just poked some fun at Manti right? You are really reaching there. I also joked about him in the mafia host thread? I even made a thread where I made some jokes with some quotes from him. Like for real where did this bullshit even come from?

 

Not because, but after. Stop twisting the narrative of my posts Quick. You started to suss me after I went to bed. Hence I interpret that you made an opportunistic move there. This is my interpretation and not a fact. It's what I make out of the stuff I was given.

So what exactly about my push was scummy? What did it make you think to change your v/v read on me and ningen? I don't grasp your read progression and I have 3 hours to get a mislynch avoided here.

 

Jesus christ kids talk with me.
it's 3 am and I don't want to wake up lynched tomorrow since I couldn't access the site the whole day.

 

Well not necessarily, that might seem obviously obvious

No, because you made it seem like it was this huuggeee service and massive issue to share it with me.
I wasn;t criticizing you or your opinion, I was making a general statement. If I didn't it would have been a waste on your part.

 

@Ratchet Vote Crimson Reaper with me. While I don't have a strong read on him at all, I would rather avoid dying here. I know that I am town and he is only the other lynch that allows town to avoid confirmed mislynch from my pov. I also think I am the more valuable member of town to keep here.
I wish Nick would stand to debate here, but Crimson Reaper is the only other lynch option.

 

I am not going to go head to head with your wall post, I'm just not. Reason for this is that its getting quite pedantic and that isn't as good at getting reads as you prolly think (if you are Town). I will say I am in no way OMGUSing you since that is impossible since it requires first a vote from you on me and then for me to vote you with little to no reasoning besides that you are voting me.

I see you making very few stances this game and you'd rather go back and forth with me than actually find and Lynch Scum. Your votes even hardly dictate your stances. You voted Lord Maple and I didn't see much of any case you made against them. You are just playing really "safe" and I don't like that at all. (I haven't looked at where your vote is yet this phase, but I saw you voted)

Your activity this phase and last has very little to do with my read on you. My read on you mostly has to do with both your tone and how you have way WAY better content as Town than you do as Scum.

I've already explained many many times why your push on Nick is Scummy. Its because your stance on Nick is that he was Rolefishing when it should be apparently obvious that he was not. It can be easily taken as a joke considering last game. On top of that, I don't see how on earth you can think Scum is so bold to rolefish so obviously so early in the Day. In short, its not a reasonable conclusion to make that he was role fishing when there are much more likely reasons for Nick doing what he was doing.

 

So instead of considering the possibility here you just rule it out? Are you for real? For me (and apparently Rot as well) it wasn't a joke. For me it seemed very genuine from him and Crimson Reaper also accepted it as an genuine push towards him.
Also wifom. You know how scum can be so bold? Because you let it go pass by for being too bold. It's the reason I lost in the schizophrenic mafia. I got accused of being a fakeclaiming sk (was actually a vig). I wrote the guy off as too dumb to be scum. See how his super stupid post that was too scummy to be scum in my eyes ended up ******* me over? I won't clear someone just because it was too bold.

Now let's see at the other things. Nick also argued over my meta. Funny thing is never in my life have I played a game with Nick. How would he be aware of my meta? As far as I recall he also never explained to me why he was arguing about my meta.

 

The problem with this is it isn't the simplest explanation. Its an argument that you can't back up because there is a lack of context for it.

So then you are assuming that Nick was thinking he might get an actual claim out of asking that? I find that very hard to believe. The only possible claim he could have gotten out of it was the same claim as last game, which is a VT claim. Its also unreasonable to expect Nick to get a claim there considering the whole thing with Rot expecting people to claim if they are Innocent or Guilty. So there would be pretty much zero reason to actually expect a claim there.

I will prolly try and reread the game because I feel I am missing a lot of pieces. Consider this prolly a pretty good thing for you.

 

I was hoping we could lynch nick but you leave me no choice.

 

Like the bold, hello. The only thing that I can possibly say this doesn't make him Scum is because there is no emoticon, and that is weak.

 

A shot was heard! @poutanko was killed by a mysterious gunman!

Show Spoiler Hide Spoiler