Normal Game Thread Full Metal Panic!: Fighting Boy Meets Girl Mafia

i agree with last part but i haven't changed mind. While CF is an informative lynch (even more than rot), i still think the chances of him being a mislynch are higher.

i can still switch to cf if this makes us hit majority before the deadline, i think.

 

Let me put it like this. I am not in any position here really to decide the lynch since I am not that much into the game. That being said, I feel like I can reason with Rot better and so I think can probably the rest of town.

Now another interesting part is that CF claimed Miller and he doesn't seem towny enough here that would warrant him to stay in the game atm. Millers are something that should be resolved imo.

 

Vote: (Crimson Falcon)

From what I read from him he is really reachy and I don't see his posts really coming from a town point of view here. Early shade is never good especially when you don't even have anything to work with and the way he even theorized was awful.

Also claimed Miller and I don't see him as townie enough to allow him to get a pass with such a claim.

 

If you guys disagree with my reasons feel free to argue

 

Valid points but im well aware what was said about him turning up town with a similar playstyle earlier this dp

Other then that all valid points

 

I see him more as 3p than mafia (jester). He did similar thing on other game (I was in that game too). He claimed cop and mentioned like 3 or 4 random names as scum so people lynch him due to him being so sus and he won. He put your name together with Rot and Daoko and later adding Maple on the list. He didn't even bother to give proper reason the 2nd time he did.

 

i forgot about the miller thing tbh.

i just think CF is the kind that plays with a non-townie style even when he's townie, and it's very easy to justify a lynch on these players although they often end up being mislynches. With this i'm not saying he's necessarily town but, for what i've seen of him, i'd be surprised to have him flip scum in this game.

 

:feelsbadman

 

Vote Tally​

Crispickle - 4 (SK, poutanko, EvilGenius, Crimson Falcon) L-4
EvilGenius - 1 (Crispickle) L-7
daoko - 1 (Lord Maple) L-7
Prada - 1 (Dr. White) L-7
Crimson Falcon - 1 (Prada) L-7

Just over 2 hours remaining. Reminder 8 votes are needed for majority. As no extension has been granted, failing to reach majority will result in the day ending with no lynch. ​

 

Musings then we shouldn't lynch him this dp then definitely.

 

I feel confident in saying that Ratchet would never include a Jester in one of his games

 

No Crisp. Lynching a miller who doesn't look that townie is the correct play. It might be some type of scum ploy after all.

 

To me the motivation behind copping someone should be to find potential scum rather than confirm potential town. Since, in practice, it amounts to the same thing given that all players have a probability of being town/scum (schematically), I can't argue much on this front so I'll drop this.
But what bothers me is that you want to direct the Cop specifically on a particular someone, whereas Cop should just pick whoever they want and we don't need to tell Mafia their target. Granted you later said that you're here and if Cop wants to they can target you, which is a wording I much prefer to your original one.

Not that obvious, if Cop dies next DP, all you'd have to say would be that Cop didn't target you and we wouldn't know if it's true.

Sign up for a game and not show up for 72 hours... I'm tempted not to give them a chance, but yeah I'd rather have them replaced by an active player than lynch them

What does that stand for?

You mean my writing style or the fact that I'm busy?

Rot listed him as having claimed innocent because he role claimed something that under normal circumstances scan innocent. Crispickle hasn't claimed what he scans (maybe I'm misremembering, but someone said that they didn't like starting the game with this kind of mass claim and I wonder if it wasn't Crisp?)

How do you know?

Cute

Look up the Traditional Mafia and You thread on OJ (Trad mafia section)

I agree with checking Venom and daoko's out of game activity to see if it's afking or silenced/lurking, I'm on phone atm so can't do that easily at the same time as posting

That's taking it backwards, he xas asking what prompted you qualify Rot's lynch as informative, whereas this interaction you're giving as example happened later, so it can't be used to justify your past statement. Why didn't you use one of Rot's past intetactions instead?

No liking Crispickle for his certainty about Dr. White, as well as his failing to explain his statements.

Vote: Crispickle

 

Musings i feel.like i should respond but i dont think theres anything really for me to say
Ill say this though i always meant for it to be that if they think they need to look into me then do it, but i just guess my wording was off.

 

Lynch The freaking Miller wtf

Also going to bed