Normal Game Thread Full Metal Panic!: Fighting Boy Meets Girl Mafia

I am in full belief that a target will only be notified in a penalty is applied.
But yes i would clear how at least right now with only one active killing role. If two begin to act her name comes back on the table

 

But that's my risk not everyone elses

 

I don't really see the risk in town forming an alliance, but okay.

 

I forgot to mention prada bizarre claim abilities there. I don't know if he thought about how to fake claim so hard to the point he had to pull stuff out of his ass to come up with stuff like that. Or it really is what he claims, I personally find it unusual tbh. Let's say we had no females in the game? what is the point of such role then? He is either a mafia who kudos to him pulled such a wonderful fake claim or it really is his role :l

However, the fact that he jumped into the guns early and role claimed without no reason looks to me like an attempt to out such a bizarre claim early on and try to convince people about his claim and make it believable.

 

If the town form an alliance scum could get in the middle and there could still be some town left out.
The people not in the alliance would be easy pickings for scum.

The female hammer thing is a bit duddeee i mean would ratchet really create a role with such a loophole like changing the genders. Lead me to think theres either more to it or it's a fake claim.
Even more huhhh then rails
Rails made somewhat sense

 

They're already easy pickings. That point is pretty invalid.

 

I have a hard time trying to understand your logic. Which part of my post is not clear enough for you?

By protecting only certain town (not even sure if they are town, only look the most town) = remaining town is in danger = guaranteed kill for mafia.

By keeping it secret on who to protect = any town can be protected = no guaranteed kill for mafia.

The bolded part, I will let people to decide which one of us is scummy. What an argument...

My sus list: Crispickle and Daoko

 

You haven't answered my question, what do you mean by "Prada is perhaps ???"? @daoko

 

The remaining townies are going to be in danger regardless. It's a moot point. Instead of leaving a confirmed townie to die, we could protect them and form an alliance. I still don't see the issue here.

And yeaaaah. I'm totally scummy for wanting town to work together. Nice job there.

 

unvote

ok now, maybe we might operate some assumptions in order to proceed.

for how weird it is that both globear and mafia have targeted poutanko last night, probably the chance of a very sophisticated ploy to clear both of them is even more remote. In case we find new stuff that makes us go back on this assumption, then we know we can lynch them together, but in any other case, i think we should start with calling them townies. Please stop me now if you think this assumption is less safe than i think

if poutanko is a townie, and since those who know the lore haven't contested his claim of prada being kurz weber based on his role, then we can assume prada is town too. This gives us a solid starting point for something that is still virtually D1.

who has something against this, speak now or hide under your blankets forever

 

unvote

 

I never said that. Here is the quote.

I was talking about Prada as a potential target to protect in order to form an alliance.

 

Who's the confirmed townie? Do we even have one? If confirmed but only vanilla, is that logical to protect vanilla over possible PR? It is possible for scum to target said vanilla but it's also possible for them to target someone else since mafia knows their team. They only need to target anyone not on their team. Just let the protective roles to do their job and choose their target freely. The mafia will have no idea who to kill this way since anyone can be under protection and mafia kill can fail.

Took me several times asking you to finally get an answer. Okay, that ??? is clear now.

 

If you actually read my post properly I wouldn't have to answer your stupid question. I literally quoted myself and repeated what I said in the quote.

As I said - according to what other people are saying in the thread - Prada is a confirmed Townie. No-one else has come forward with a role reveal that would work out better.

Scum targeting other people outside of the confirmed alliance is perfectly fine. It's inevitable. It's the point of the game. What are the mafia supposed to do - not choose a night target???? I'm fine with Globear just doing whatever she wants, but the chances of her consistently protecting someone from harm every single night is very slim. I'd rather put my faith into protecting a trusted town member - keeping them alive is more of a benefit to town.

 

This looks like you just rephrased what I said and wrote it down in your way. Don't really like it.

Why we would assume prada is townie? his case is very very VERY different than globear and pouta case. I find his claim to be bizarre and makes little sense tbh. I talked more about it in details in my previous posts.