Show Your Colors 1 - Voting Thread!

Umm, that's it.
So only 10 is good and the rest don't need any feedback? :/

 

only one work is worth my vote so that's a feedback to the creator since I obviously liked his work

 

As you wish...

 

??? others are not worth ? ^^
I take it as you meant that it is your favorite
but please give more feedback, why did you chose this entry among others ?

 

Couse the way he did it,it's clean well colored and I feel it's nice.Also the shadows looks decent I feel like that's the winner in my eyes if not in general.

 

well this is a nice and decent post ^^ your first one was just provocating on purpose.

i like 4 the best coz I like the warm and comforting colors :D

 

what? I am just used to reward my only vote to someone I really think stands out more than others.

 

Yo this is alright to want to reward the only and one winner. :D I didnt like your choice of words in your first post in that thread tbh coz it was provocating on purpose. :O
ok i make my last post.

 

Seriously can you guys just shush it. Please? For a moment?
Have a slice of cake.
It's a competition, there can be tweaks, but going on and on isnt fun, arent forums meant to be fun?

 

I want to vote for 7 since he/she colored a 7th Garden panel, but 6 is the best by far. 5 is hella slept on too.

 

And here are the results

1st Place @wowee - 460
2nd Place @Underworld Broker - 300
3rd Place @Machi - 165
all other - 100

Entries
1 - @Know
2 - @Shanksette
3 - @Naruko uzumaki
4- @wowee
5 - @Crimson Falcon
6- @Nomad
7 - @Ningen
8 - @EvilGenius
9 - @Machi
10 - @Underworld Broker

Feedback
1st - Good improvement from past, The grass and sky looked fantastic tho try smaller brush strokes from grass next time. Blond color was done real good. Some depth in skin shading would be good, Keep it up
2nd - Black/blue suits look good and clean BG makes it nice but it needs shading, and glow felt abruptly out of place. Instead of showing light source it made the two characters light bulb, So avoid that and the standing girl blue could be tone lower as its distracting from overall flow, Keep it up.
3rd - Good color choices and mostly clean but the white HL at hair is waay too much in volume and needs to be spread more over the hair. Skin softness is done very well but needs some HL blending since hard white HL in soft overall shading feels odd. Keep it up and you can move up in no time
4th - Overall a great coloring but the hell is that light source . Girl skirt is making it bottom right source going above but the arms sleeves contradict it with top left source coming diagonal, then her hair near face along with cloth on back is showing right side source. Git Gud and kys
5th - Base is good but Fog is too white and apparent making it look like bad case of glow, Needs some shading. Keep it up
6th - Hair is bland needs shading, eyes look nice, with top right LS which most of ur shading is based on, The girls right ass cheek [ left for us] and her shirt above should be darker with no white HL. Light is being blocked naturally regardless of Viewer angle there. Same with bedsheet because your coloring of those parts is suggesting 2 ls from both sides but overall shading is suggesting single top right. Keep it up
7th - I knew it went shit moment I started BG /shrug tho happy with skin
8th - Good bases, some unclean spots tho. Needs shading really to bring out pic potential tho great BG and wings. Keep it up
9th - The best one for me, The wood is done soo nice and usage of LS in cloths dim light shading is perfect tho judging from amout of HL done on face and chest cloth its apparent cloths on leg needed albeit more of HL considering they are closest to LS. The pillow looks amazing too. Keep it up
10th - The fact it wasnt HL'ed to hell and beyond already makes its quite good to me the skull and its hair looks amazing but you went overboard on Skin green shading, at this point she looks poisoned and about to drop dead with amount of green on her skin. You did sunlight on boar but did not do it on the skin itself, Green plants in forest mid wont reflect that much light to make you that much in green. You needed to coat it with sunlight to keep it okay cuz main LS is sun itself and plants with secondary reflection source which got treatment of main LS on skin. Overall great coloring and something different from ur usual.

again all this is what I saw, You and others can have different viewpoints and thats fine.

All feedback on mine is appreciated.

SYC 2 will be made soon


Thanks for taking part

 

Congrats guys!!!

 

Will spread out the prizes.

 

All prizes sent, Congratulations to the winners!

 

#SomeDay i'll give you a panel that is fully shaded and has HL